Guest Blog: Why should European democracy matter?

Activists of the Party of European Socialists (PES) are campaigning for the PES to hold pan-European primary elections to choose the party’s candidate for the Presidency of the European Commsison in 2014. Declining turnout in European elections, democratic deficit or disconnect and an abiding feeling that the EU is remote and over-complicated all strengthen the demand for more democracy in the European Union. Decisions are made for us, especially in the European Commission, by people with an unsatisfactory mandate from us. The Campaign for a PES Primary tackles this head-on.

The Irish government is utterly overwhelmed by and patently unfit to address the profound crises that Ireland is suffering, but what of the EU’s response? With its eurozone structures, capacity to co-ordinate and lead government action and substantial budgets for regional and structural funding the EU possesses significant resources to bring us through these difficult times. But the European Commission has demonstrated extraordinary lassitude in mobilising a continent-wide effort to create jobs, protect standards of living and promote strategies for economic recovery and growth. Led by José Manuel Barroso, the Commission has shown itself unequal to the task.

The Commission likes to portray itself as a college of independent, supra-national public servants, but in reality it is a highly political institution. Its membership reflects the political affiliations of national governments, and it is confirmed in office by a European Parliament, whose political configuration the governments are obliged to observe in their choice of Commission President. As the Conservatives, represented in Ireland by Fine Gael, “won” the European elections last June, it is their representative, José Manuel Barroso, who was returned to office as Commission President. It is the outcome of those elections that has given us a Commission that has shown such crippling complacency and disregard.

The Party of European Socialists (PES), however, had a disappointing election. In Ireland, the Labour Party (PES) trebled its tally of MEPs, but elsewhere parties of the Left, especially in Britain, Germany and France, were held as much to blame for the crisis as the Right. Though national party leaders agreed a common election manifesto that pledged to put people rather than markets first, they failed to agree on a PES candidate for the Presidency of the Commission who would personify and articulate that manifesto. Iberian loyalties and a British prime minister closer to Barroso than to his own political family torpedoed efforts to present an agreed PES candidate. The PES “lost” the last European elections, but it is Europe’s citizens who have paid the price of a Commission unequal to the task of securing our jobs and living standards.

Recognising its own responsibility, the PES agreed political and organisational changes at its Prague Congress last December designed to further integrate the PES and national parties and resolved to present a single candidate for Commission President at the next European elections in 2014. This is a landmark decision and it has raised a vital question; how is that candidate to be selected?

The Party of European Socialists is the only pan-European party with an activists layer formally recognised in its statutes and comprising some 20,000 activists and over 100 citygroups, including Dublin and Belfast. These activists are campaigning for the PES candidate for the Commission Presidency in 2014 to be selected by the members of all of the PES national parties. We want “primary elections” to be held in every PES national party, including the Labour Party in Ireland, where candidates will compete for the opportunity to lead the PES campaign and win the Presidency of the European Commission.

Just imagine the interest, energy and passion that such a process would release. A democratically selected PES candidate for Commission President would possess an enhanced legitimacy and a mandate for positive change in Europe. The PES European election campaign in 2014 would be hugely energised and we might finally see a truly “European” election campaign emerge that engages citizens by demonstrating that who we vote for in Europe really can make a difference to our daily lives. A PES President of the European Commission would herald a new direction for Europe and lead the effort to create a Social Europe that puts people first. This is the vision that PES activists want to enable. If you share our vision or would like to know more come visit us at

Desmond O’Toole is co-ordinator of PES activists Dublin and is a member of the Irish Labour Party and the Parti Socialiste. He is jointly organising the Campaign for a PES Primary with José Reis Santos, co-ordinator of PES activists Portugal. Launched on the 26th July, their Facebook campaign page has attracted the support of over 500 PES activists and supporters in just two weeks.

2 thoughts on “Guest Blog: Why should European democracy matter?

  1. @ David Morris

    Is this the EUSSR that encourages the free movement of goods, services, capital and people, and is dominated by the centre-right in the Council, Parliament and Commission? It must be a very failed EUSSR if it can’t even get a one-party Communist state right.

  2. Jeez

    Just what is needed, another socialist boondoggle.

    Message from Real World to PES – There is no more money left to waste on your busted EUSSR Project.

    Kind regards

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *